Picture this: You’re in a high-stakes design review. Stakeholders are pushing back, developers are raising concerns, and your carefully crafted user experience seems to be unravelling before your eyes. Your heart races as you scramble for a way to salvage your vision. Now, imagine handling this situation with the calm, calculated approach of an FBI hostage negotiator. Sounds far-fetched? Think again.
In the world of UX design, we’re constantly negotiating – with users, stakeholders, team members, and even our own assumptions. That’s why the principles outlined in Chris Voss’s book “Never Split the Difference: Negotiating As If Your Life Depended On It {Amazon}” are surprisingly applicable to our field. As a former FBI hostage negotiator, Voss’s tactics aren’t just for high-pressure criminal situations; they’re invaluable tools for anyone looking to enhance their communication and persuasion skills.
Over the next three articles, we’ll explore powerful techniques from the FBI negotiator’s playbook that can revolutionise your UX design process:
- Active Listening and Mirroring: Uncover user needs like never before.
- Calibrated Questions: Transform your discovery phase and stakeholder management.
- Labelling Emotions: Enhance your empathy mapping and conflict resolution skills.
Today, we’ll focus on active listening and mirroring – two techniques that can help you uncover user needs with the precision of a skilled negotiator.
The art of listening: More than just hearing
Imagine you’re an FBI negotiator, tasked with de-escalating a tense hostage situation. Every word, every pause, every inflection in the hostage-taker’s voice could be crucial. You’re not just hearing words; you’re absorbing every nuance, every hidden meaning. This is active listening at its most intense.
In UX design, while the stakes may be lower, the principle remains the same. Active listening is about fully concentrating on, understanding, and responding to what’s being said. It’s giving your full attention to the speaker, showing that you’re listening through verbal and non-verbal cues, and providing thoughtful feedback.
But how do you show you’re really listening? This is where mirroring comes in.
Mirroring: The secret weapon of understanding
Mirroring, a key component of active listening, involves repeating the last few words or key phrases your conversation partner has used. It sounds simple, almost too simple. But as Chris Voss explains in “Never Split the Difference,” this technique builds rapport and encourages the speaker to elaborate, often revealing crucial information they might not have shared otherwise.
Let’s see how these techniques play out in different UX scenarios:
Scenario 1: The user interview
You’re redesigning a mobile plan selection interface. During a user interview, Sarah, a busy professional, mentions:
“I find it hard to choose the right plan.”
Instead of moving on to your next prepared question, you mirror: “You find it hard to choose the right plan?”
Sarah elaborates: “Yeah, there are so many options. I’m never sure if I’m getting the best value for my usage. Plus, I travel occasionally for work, and I’m not clear on how that affects my plan.”
This additional information, prompted by a simple mirror, opens up a world of insights. You’ve uncovered multiple pain points:
- Overwhelming number of options
- Difficulty in assessing value for personal usage
- Confusion about international roaming implications
These insights could lead to several UX improvements:
- A smart plan recommendation tool considering typical usage and travel habits
- Clearer visualisations of plan benefits, especially for international features
- A comparison feature highlighting differences between plans based on user-specific criteria
You decide to dig deeper: “You’re not clear on how travel affects your plan?”
Sarah responds: “Right. Sometimes I end up with unexpected charges. It would be great if I could easily see or simulate how my trips might impact my bill.”
This further mirroring has revealed even more potential features:
- A travel impact calculator within the plan selection interface
- Proactive notifications about plan adjustments when users book travel
- A clearer presentation of roaming benefits within each plan’s description
Scenario 2: The usability test
Now, let’s fast forward. You’ve implemented some changes based on your interviews, and you’re conducting a usability test on the new interface. Tom, another participant, is trying to select a plan that suits his needs.
As Tom navigates the interface, he mumbles:
“I’m not sure what this symbol means.”
You mirror: “You’re not sure what this symbol means?”
Tom elaborates: “Yeah, I’ve seen it before on other apps, but I can never remember if it’s for settings or for more options. It’s not very descriptive.”
This response provides specific feedback about Tom’s mental model and the effectiveness of your iconography. It highlights a potential issue with your navigation design that might have been missed without this prompt for elaboration.
Scenario 3: The stakeholder meeting
Now, imagine you’re in a meeting with key stakeholders to discuss the proposed changes to the mobile plan selection interface. The head of marketing, John, expresses concern:
“I’m worried these changes might negatively impact our upsell opportunities.”
Instead of immediately defending your design decisions, you mirror: “You’re worried about the impact on upsell opportunities?”
John elaborates: “Yes, our current interface allows us to prominently feature our premium plans. If we simplify too much, we might lose the chance to showcase the added value of these options.”
This response reveals John’s underlying concern about maintaining revenue streams and highlights a potential conflict between user needs and business goals. By using active listening and mirroring, you’ve uncovered a crucial perspective that needs to be addressed in your design solution.
You decide to dig deeper: “You’re concerned about showcasing the added value?”
John responds: “Exactly. We need to ensure that users can easily see the benefits of our higher-tier plans. It’s not just about simplification, it’s about effective communication of value.”
This exchange has revealed several important points:
- The need to balance simplification with effective upselling
- The importance of clearly communicating the value of premium plans
- A potential opportunity to reimagine how premium features are presented within a simplified interface
By actively listening and mirroring in this stakeholder meeting, you’ve gained valuable insights that will help you refine your design to better align with both user needs and business objectives. You can now work on solutions that simplify the user experience while still effectively showcasing the value of premium plans.
The impact on your UX process
By incorporating active listening and mirroring into your UX toolkit, you’re not just gathering data – you’re uncovering stories. You’re not just ticking boxes on a usability checklist – you’re understanding the why behind user behaviours. This approach leads to:
1. Richer, more nuanced user insights
2. Stronger relationships with stakeholders and users
3. Identification of pain points and opportunities that might otherwise go unnoticed
4. Designs that more accurately reflect user needs and expectations
From hostage negotiation to user negotiation
Active listening and mirroring aren’t just for FBI negotiators defusing high-stakes situations. They’re powerful tools that can transform your UX design process, helping you navigate the complex terrain of user needs and expectations.
As you integrate these techniques into your work, you’ll find yourself not just designing interfaces, but crafting experiences that truly resonate with your users. You’ll be negotiating your way to better design, one conversation at a time.
Remember, like any skill, these techniques improve with practice. Start small by incorporating mirroring into your next user interview or usability test. Pay attention to the results – you might be surprised at the depth of information you uncover.
In our next article, we’ll explore how calibrated questions can transform your discovery phase and stakeholder management. Stay tuned to learn how this powerful FBI negotiation technique can take your UX design process to the next level.
So, are you ready to listen actively and mirror your way to better UX design? The floor is yours – go negotiate your way to uncovering user needs like never before!
More in this series
- Calibrated Questions: Transform your discovery phase and stakeholder management.
- Labelling Emotions: Enhance your empathy mapping and conflict resolution skills.
Get the book
Get your own copy of the book that inspired this series “FBI Tactics for UX Design” .
Discover the groundbreaking negotiation techniques that revolutionised FBI hostage situations, now applied to UX design. Get your hands on the bestselling book that inspired this eye-opening series and transform your approach to user experience!” from Amazon